Yoga and Pilates are often taught in similar rooms, on similar mats, and both involve breathing and controlled movement. But they come from different traditions and put the emphasis in different places.
Where they come from
Yoga is, in the words of the U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), “an ancient and complex practice, rooted in Indian philosophy.” It began as a spiritual practice and has become popular as a way of promoting physical and mental well-being.
Pilates is an exercise method. A systematic review of 119 research papers found general agreement in how the literature defines it: a mind-body exercise focused on strength, core stability, flexibility, muscle control, posture and breathing.
What a class usually includes
| Yoga | Pilates | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical elements | Physical postures, breathing techniques and meditation (as commonly practiced in the U.S., per NCCIH) | Exercises for strength, core stability, flexibility, muscle control and posture, with attention to breathing |
| Equipment | Usually a mat; props vary by class | Mat-based, or specialized equipment |
| Range of styles | Many styles, from gentle to physically demanding | Mat and equipment classes; traditional principles are emphasized to different degrees |
| Mind-body element | Meditation and breathing are part of many classes | Described as a mind-body exercise; breathing is one of its traditional principles |
The review also found that Pilates’ traditional principles (centering, concentration, control, precision, flow and breathing) were discussed in only about a quarter of papers on average. In other words, what “Pilates” means in practice can vary between classes and studies, and so can “yoga.”
Which is better?
Neither is better in general; it depends on what you want from a class. NCCIH notes that differences in the types of yoga used in research studies may affect study results. When an article claims one beats the other, check what was actually compared, in whom, and for which outcome.
Practical questions are often more useful:
- Do you want a meditative or breathing element, or mainly a structured exercise class?
- Is the class mat-based, or does it use equipment?
- What level is it for, and can you ask the instructor questions?
For the practical side of a first class, see Your First Yoga Class: What to Bring and What to Ask, and for online options, Live vs. Recorded Online Yoga Classes: A Beginner’s Comparison.
Safety
NCCIH describes yoga as generally safe for healthy people when practiced properly with a qualified instructor, while noting that injuries can occur. Whichever you choose, if you are pregnant, older, recovering from an injury or have a health condition, talk with a health care provider and tell the instructor before you start.